Shake-up of planning committees: what it means for your home extension
Councillors face ban on deciding householder planning applications under Government proposals
Planning rules in England are set for a major shake-up and it could change how you get the go-ahead for your dream extension. The Government wants to simplify and speed up how planning decisions are made. Under the proposals, all householder applications could be decided by planning officers alone without input from local councillors. Elected members would also lose the power to block developments of up to nine homes or up to 50 homes in big cities like London.
Ministers say this could lead to thousands of more homes being built a year, by reducing delays and refusals. But planning experts have warned it will also weaken local democracy and make it harder to challenge unfair decisions.
The proposals are still in consultation stage at the time of writing this article (June 2025), so nothing is set in stone yet. To become law, the proposals would need to be passed by Parliament.
What’s being proposed?
- Homeowner applications – like extensions, loft conversions and self-builds - will only be decided by planning officers. The option for ward councillors to “call-in” projects to be decided by planning committee instead will be scrapped.
- Small housing schemes – up to nine homes or 50 in big cities like London - could skip planning committee (local democratic) scrutiny entirely.
- Councils would follow the same national rules for when an application is decided by planning committee. At present, each council has its own rules.
- Planning committees might only consider applications if both the chief planning officer and the elected chair agree democratic scrutiny was needed. This is expected to include the biggest and most controversial schemes.
- Planning committees would be smaller and possibly include non-elected independent experts. They would focus on strategic development.
- Councillors would need to complete compulsory training before they can sit on planning committees.
- Councils could set their own planning fees. This could increase costs for home extenders and self-builders.
What is a planning committee?
A planning committee is a group of elected councillors who meet in public to decide certain planning applications. They receive a written report from a planning officer summarising the proposal, relevant policies and laws, previous applications on the site, public comments (both objections and support) and a recommendation to approve, refuse or defer a decision for a site visit or more information.
Councillors debate, ask questions and vote. Under the current system, homeowners or their architect or planning consultant can address the committee although time is strictly limited – usually two or three minutes per application. This opportunity to lobby decision makers in public and for elected representatives to hear the views both in favour and against an application will be lost under the proposed reforms.
Planning committees usually follow the planning officers’ recommendations - but they don’t have to. At present, they have the power to approve or reject an application against the case officer’s advice.
Planning officers and delegated decisions
Most applications, especially smaller ones like home extensions, never go to committee. They’re decided by professional planning officers using what’s called “delegated powers.” But when proposals are more complex or controversial or if a ward councillor asks for it, the application can be “called in” for the committee to decide.
In the last quarter of 2024, 96 per cent of applications were determined by planning officers, up from 75 per cent in 2000, according to government figures. However, the number and type of applications committees consider still varies widely between local authorities. At present, some planning committees will deal with most applications while others will determine relatively few, says Whitehall.
At present, each council sets its own rules for what gets referred to committee. Government wants to change that, making the process more standardised across England with fewer opportunities for councillors to go against officer advice.
Ministers argue involving councillors in smaller applications causes delays, inconsistency and uncertainty. And there is insufficient understanding among all committee members of planning principles and law, leading to decisions which can be overturned on appeal and wasting taxpayers’ money.
Housing minister Matthew Pennycock, told The Times, he wanted to remove councillors from “swathes” of planning applications, saying this would “increase the certainty and speed at which planning decisions are made.”
Expert views: why planning committees still matter
Simon Rix, a professional planning consultant and director of Planix UK Planning Consultants Ltd, says planning committees can be “a powerful tool” for self-builders and home extenders facing resistance from planning officers. Elected councillors may give the go-ahead when officers have repeatedly rejected a proposal after significant redesigns or fresh justifications. In his experience, many committee call-ins result in consents even after multiple refusals by officers.
He advises clients to ask local ward councillors to call in an application before launching a formal appeal which can take longer and cost more.
Rix believes that removing planning committees from homeowner cases could lead to more refusals. “I’m all in favour of speeding up the process but officers often unnecessarily block applications while councillors bring common sense to a project,” he says.
While planning officers make decisions based on national and local planning policy and law, it is often their interpretation, according to rix. “Often the standard position is to say ‘no’. They don’t see things from the point of view of the citizen quite as clearly as local councillors who after all are elected to represent them.
“In my view, a planning committee is a good thing. It’s a way of getting things approved because the mindset of officers is often negative. Sometimes only way to get through bureaucracy is through the councillors.”
Alice Drew, a director of Southern Planning Practice, warns the proposals risk undermining local democracy. “Banning councillors from making decisions on householder applications may speed the process up, however it will potentially result in the loss of local community input,” she says. “The current tiered delegation scheme is designed to balance efficiency and democracy. However, unfortunately, due to lack of resourcing, the efficiency element has been lost.”
Asked whether more officer-only decisions would be faster, the planning consultant says: “Yes, it’s likely to speed up decision making as the application will not be held for a future committee meeting. However, this is only the case if the council is well resourced with efficient, pragmatic case officers.”
She adds: “While decisions under delegated powers may be slightly faster and more predictable than a planning committee decision, there is a need to maintain committee oversight when there are controversial applications which have attracted a lot of public objections.
“Removing the power from committees and giving it to officers for householder applications may mean that applications which have been potentially politically driven will end up at appeal.”
Smaller committees, better training
Rix supports the idea of smaller planning committees and mandatory training for councillors. Drew agrees. “I believe that smaller, well-trained committees will improve efficiency and fair, educated decision making.”
Asked how she would improve the system, Drew says more government investment “to train and retain good planning officers.” The planning consultant is also in favour of bypassing planning officers in straightforward cases. She explains: “applications strictly compliant with both local and national planning policies would be automatically approved and officers would only review applications that are contrary to policy or have significant objections.”.
Planning fees
Currently the cost of applying for planning permission in England is £258. This is the cost of householder applications, including extensions and significant alterations. However, if you are building a new house the cost rises to £578. A government impact study estimates that local planning authorities could raise an additional £1.1m annually if they set their own fees.
Rix is opposed to variable fees, saying it will lead to “a new postcode lottery.” He adds: “The system is so complicated already to have different fees across the country is going to add to the complexity.” He supports a higher national fixed fee to better fund under-resourced planning departments.
Drew can see the pros and cons. “I do think some planning application fees are too low and others too high at present in the national fee framework,” she says. “Therefore, if local planning authorities are willing to offer an efficient, pragmatic service then I believe our clients would be willing to pay more for this. However, I do think that the system of having a national set fee does work and this would add an additional complexity when calculating the fee and submitting applications.”
If approved, these reforms could make it quicker and easier to get planning permission for extensions and self-builds. But it will also mean more decisions taken behind closed doors, unreported by the local press. And removing councillor input will limit the ability to challenge unreasonable refusals by planning officers before launching an appeal.
Blob) For more details on the proposed reforms, see Reform Working Paper: Planning Committees (Feb, 2025) and Reform of Planning Committees: Technical Consultation (May 2025).